No, not Trick or Treat!, or as Dad calls it, 'Begging for Candy'. Instead, this is a question--Will a new show be a Trick, or a Treat?
But first, apologies. This post was supposed to be written and posted earlier, even if only earlier today, but a week-long conference I was assisting with at work prevented. Also, it's late at night, so hopefully my thoughts aren't too disjointed.
So, the show. I first saw an ad for it on TV about 2 months ago, but didn't quite connect it. The only parts that stick out now were some importance being attached to a sword, and a woman in a long white dress kicking man in the head with a Crescent kick. The title: "Legend of the Seeker". I thought, nah, that can't be it; it's like calling a show based on "The Chronicles of Narnia", "Stories of the Lion". I mean, you could do it, but it isn't the most intuitive. Turns out, they did.
The show is based on the "Sword of Truth" series; the man (or woman) who wields The Sword is called 'The Seeker', short for 'The Seeker of Truth'. There are 11 books in the series, which is a really odd number. Something like 10 or 12 would be more common, but that's it ended. When I read the first one (despite the next few), I thought OK, great, this wrapped up nicely, only to find out in subsequent books that it really didn't. Again, it's kind of like "The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe". If that was the only book in the series you read, the story would be complete. Add another one, though, and it's not complete until "the Last Battle". Difference here is, as I read The Sword of Truth, the story was wrapped up after one book. After 2 books, while not complete, it could have ended just fine there. Same with 3 and 4--bad guys in defeat, everyone's happy (or at least on the road to happiness), etc. But no. Beginning with book 5, they all end with a bit of cliff-hanger, until the 11th.
While I liked the series, I don't unreservedly recommend it. In movie ratings: Language is probably PG; violence, PG-13. Sex is probably also PG-13, but maybe a little higher. Other issue: Preachy author. The author is heavily influenced by Ayn Rand and her philosophy of Objectivism; this comes out in discussions between some of the characters. While it does have some good points (like against communist-types, "fairness", etc), some of the arguments (like in religious areas) are straw-men--arguments that look tough, but don't stand up to a good question or two.
Comparing to a common standard: Take the Belgariad/Mallorean. Now, figure out how much more elevated some of the above themes are presented in Elenium/Tamuli. Take them that much higher from there, and you're at about the level of Sword of Truth.
OK, so I like the series (book); seeing it made into a TV series is (or has the potential to be) a Treat. Especially true since the author is involved in the development. So, why am I concerned it might be a Trick? Well, some things in the previews were not how they played out in the books. OK, some of this could be artistic license (like the death of Denae (sp?)) being in real-time, instead of flash-back. Others are questionable. I'm talking about costumes here--maybe not that important, but clothes do play critical roles in key points in the books (the first one, at least). Others look to complete fabrications--new characters, and a complete change of The Quest (you did know there was a quest, right?). Yes, the ultimate goal (defeat the bad guy) is there, but the means (steps to get there) have completely changed. How do I know? A couple things in the trailers, and reading the episode descriptions.
So, I guess we'll just have to wait and see. It could end up being really good, like "Lord of the Rings". It may even drop to the level of "Harry Potter", where the basic storyline is intact, just with pieces cut and moved around to make it fit. If that's as far as deviations from the books occur, that would be OK. Much further than that, though, and not so much. Then, it would be like...some really good book that was an awful movie. None spring immediately to mind, but I know there have been some. Maybe in the next week or so I'll provide my thoughts, after the first 2 episodes air (Saturday! TODAY!)
Here's the website; what do you think? http://www.legendoftheseeker.com/index.html

No comments:
Post a Comment